Five things we learned building a multiplex pro forma


Hi Reader,

Over the last couple of weeks, we ran our first Toronto Multiplex Feasibility Workshop.

In two sessions, we built a sample multiplex pro forma from the ground up—and then tried to break it.

I did not want this to become an Excel workshop. The spreadsheet is useful, but the real question we kept coming back to was:

Does this project actually make sense as an investment—and can the owner carry it?

A few key takeaways.

1. A pro forma is not a prediction tool.

A pro forma is our best attempt at putting numbers to the uncertainties of the development journey.

It is a planning and risk-management tool. Its job is not to prove that the project works. Its job is to show us what needs to be true for it to work—and what could cause it not to.

2. Development is the process. The investment is what you own at the end.

The building still needs to operate after the architects, engineers and contractors have moved on.

The decisions we make about unit mix, sound control, storage, parking, finishes and building systems eventually show up in rents, vacancy, operating costs and tenant turnover.

3. A good-looking project is not necessarily a financeable project.

You might have a model that works on paper, but the lender is also looking at the borrower.

Do you have enough net worth and liquidity? Can you support the project at peak equity? Do you have the right experience and team around you?

At the end of the day, the project and the borrower both need to qualify.

4. Your rent assumption decides the deal.

That number affects value, debt capacity, the equity left in the project, annual cash flow and eventual returns. This is why the rent assumption cannot simply be whatever number makes the spreadsheet work.

You need to understand what tenants in that location will actually pay—and what they will not.

5. HST and ownership structure cannot be dealt with at the end.

The HST treatment, potential rebates, timing of payments and the legal structure between partners can all affect how much cash the project needs and who carries the risk.

These are not lines we should add to the model after everything else has already been decided.

Quite frankly, not every project should move forward.

The purpose of the pro forma is to help us get closer to one of three decisions:

Proceed. Revise. Or walk away.

Thanks to our guest contributors: Mike Zavershnik - 17A Properties, Hamia Aghaiemeybodi - TopDot Architects, Abtin Nikeghbali - Canada ICI, Rami Miransky and Mostafa Hosseini - BeeEquity for sharing their experience with the group.

We are now planning the next workshop.

If you own a property—or are actively evaluating one—and would like to receive the next dates and early-access information, you can join the waitlist below.

Best,

Payam Noursalehi

New Here? Start with these five:

​(2) Risk, Creativity, & Design Excellence: Real Estate Development with Sheldon Rosen​

​(28) How To Raise Capital For Real Estate Development? - David Roff - Cranson Capital​

​(33) 4-Plex to Mid-Rise: Best Development Opportunities in the GTA - Blair Scorgie - Scorgie Planning​

​(38) Financing Purpose-Built Rentals - Max Goyzman - Peakhill Capital​

​(20) Legal Structures in Real Estate Development - Zev Zlotnick from Gardiner Roberts LLP​

​

Was this email forwarded to you?​
Join our email list to receive future articles, podcast episodes, and practical insights on real estate development and construction directly in your inbox.

​

330 Highway 7 E, Richmond Hill, ON L4B 3P8
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Payam Noursalehi

Real estate development is full of expensive decisions, incomplete information, and avoidable risk. Subscribe for practical insights on feasibility, approvals, financing, pre-construction, construction management, and project delivery—along with new episodes of the Real Estate Development Insights Podcast, articles, and upcoming events.

Read more from Payam Noursalehi
year of the mid-rise

New Episode: (65) Toronto Mid-Rise: What’s Changed and What Still Holds Projects Back? Claire Malcolmson Her career has focused on securing and sustaining policy wins for environmental causes for Lake Simcoe, the Great Lakes, and municipal election financing reform. Her current role as a consulting Lobbyist to Environmental Defence flows from the organization and Claire’s history of fighting sprawl and supporting smart growth and infill development. Interested In Making Mid-Rise Projects...

New Episode: (64) From Architect to Multiplex Developer: Lessons from the Site Noam Hazan OAA, FRAIC, LEED AP, WELL AP is an OAA-licensed architect, developer and founder of NHDS, a Toronto practice focused on multiplexes, missing-middle housing and custom residential projects. Alongside designing multiplexes for clients, Noam is developing a fourplex and garden suite of his own, taking on the roles of architect, co-owner and general contractor. Interested In Making Mid-Rise Projects Work?...

(63) Building Small Mid-Rise in Toronto: What Developers Need to Know - Heather Dubbeldam & Derek McCallum

New Episode: (63) Building Small Mid-Rise in Toronto: What Developers Need to Know Building Small Mid-Rise Heather Dubbeldam OAA, FRAIC, LEED AP, WELL AP is the founding Principal and Creative Director of Dubbeldam Architecture + Design, a Toronto practice recognized for design excellence and its commitment to sustainability. Under her leadership, the firm received the Royal Architectural Institute of Canada’s 2024 Architectural Practice Award. Derek McCallum M.Arch, OAA, LEED Green Associate...